Truth Be Told – Part 1, continued: Truth is a Story

Dragnet1DRAGNET WAS A POPULAR TV POLICE DRAMA in the 1950s and 60s, featuring dramatized actual cases from the Los Angeles Police Department. The main character, Sergeant Joe Friday (played by Jack Webb), was a terse, no-nonsense cop just looking to solve cases and catch crooks as quickly and efficiently as possible. When interrogating any witnesses who might offer extra opinions or emotional side trips (usually a woman; it was the 50s and 60s), Friday would cut them off with, “All we want are the facts, ma’am” (not the “Just the facts, ma’am” of legend). All that mattered to Friday were the relevant data necessary to reaching a definitive conclusion to a criminal inDragnet2vestigation, to put it analytically. All he wanted were the bits and pieces of the truth as the way things really are, narrowly constrained to a narrow purpose. But even in the context of the show we learn that facts do not, and cannot, just hang in mid-air. Every episode of Dragnet began with the narration, “The story you are about to see is true,” and ended with, “The story you have just seen is true.” So, it turns out that what Sergeant Friday weavingwas really trying to do was not just accumulate isolated, unconnected facts, but find the narrative in which all these facts made sense, the complete and true story of the crime he was investigating. This is the way Truth is. The bits and pieces of “facts”, the threads of truth, only make sense when they are woven together into one seamless story, a story of the way things really are.

There are small stories, Big Stories, and metanarratives. These are not watertight categories; not until “metanarrative” anyway. Joe Friday’s crime-solving scenario is a small story. Joe Friday’s life story is also a small story. A history of the Los Angeles Police Department is bigger than Joe Friday’s story, but not yet really a Big Story. A Big Story does offer a much larger context in which to place and make more sense of our smalrussian dollsler stories. A history of the settlement and development of the United States of America is definitely a Big Story, but it fits into a bigger Big Story, the history of Western Civilization from ancient Rome to the present; etc. Something like nesting Russian dolls. A history of the human race would be a really big Big Story; but if were only a straight chronology of historical events, facts, dates, and personages, it would not yet be a metanarrative.

A Big Story becomes a metanarrative when it offers answers (any answers, not necessarily correct ones) to life’s ultimate questions, such as Why are we here?, What is the meaning to our existence?, Where did everything come from?, etc. A meta-narrative is a Narrative about narratives; a Story about stories. And a metanarrative makes the (rather bold) claim that all the other stories—big ones, small ones, and even other stories that also claim to be metanarratives—are best understood and explained in the context of that metanarrative. Major world religions—Hinduism, Buddhism, Judaism, Christianity, Islam, etc.—are, among other things, metanarratives. So are Atheistic Materialist, Secular Humanism (or Secular Progressivism, take your pick), and Marxism.

When the late philosopher Richard Rorty denied that there was any such thing as truth rorty“Truth” (with a capital T), he was dismissing the possibility of there being any such thing as a valid metanarrative; there was no one True Story that made sense of all stories. This denial—or “incredulity toward metanarratives” as French philosopher Jean-Francois Lyotard put it—is the beating heart of what is called the “postmodern” condition. As a declaration of the actual nature of reality, the denial of metanarratives is, of course, self-evidently nonsense. It’s like saying, “the Truth is there is no Truth.” The denial of metanarratives is a metanarrative, and one that claims to be absolutely true for everybody. It is a declaration that there is no meaning to the universe. But as C.S. Lewis pointed out in Mere Christianity, “If the universe has no meaning we should not have found out that it has no meaning; just as, if there were no light in the universe and therefore no creatures with eyes, we should never know it was dark. ‘Dark’ would be without meaning.” In a meaningless universe, ‘meaningless’ would have no meaning.

whateverOn the other hand, the phrase “incredulity toward metanarratives” is a good description (if a bit technical) of a certain lightly tossed contemporary attitude that we need take little or no account of serious explanations, deeper issues, ultimate questions, or Truth. A less technical description of it would be the attitude of “Whatever.” But, to make a long argument short, this attitude only works, and works only for a short while, amongst privileged younger people in industrialized societies who have sufficient material resources to fund a “Whatever” lifestyle for awhile. Besides, the attitude is also disingenuous, delusional, or both.

We cannot escape our desire and drive toward metanarrative. We all want to know what fragments1the meaning of our existence is. We all want to know if there is a True Story that will tell us who we really are. Our life comes to us and we gather it only in fragments. We read, we are told, or we imagine the whole and so try to arrange all the pieces of our lives in some way that we hope will tell us who we are, and why we are. And when we have assembled enough pieces we build stories and try to tell ourselves who we are, and why we are. We want our stories to all be true and to all have happy endings, yet often they jostle and bump one another, sometimes they clash and break. Beauty and despair, anger and love, mix and tumble violently. Often the stories we tell ourselves as much conceal hurt as they reveal truth. It is sometimes hard to tell what the truth is, and harder still to tell the truth, even to ourselves. How can we know what the True Story of our lives is?


Next Week: Truth Be Told—Part 2: How Can We Know What The Truth Is?


About Michael W Nicholson

I am a follower of Jesus Christ, a husband, father, and grandfather, a brother and a friend. My professional career has been in education. I taught Industrial Arts in Middle School for six years, four years as an adjunct professor in theology and philosophy, and fifteen years teaching classes in Old Testament, Apologetics, and Worldviews in a Christian High School. Like everyone else who breathes in American culture, I am infected with chronic postmodernity, but I am aware of this and regularly administer the treatment: Historic Christian Orthodoxy as contained in the Scriptures of the Old & New Testaments. I am fascinated by almost every subject imaginable, except economics. I have a Ph.D. in systematic theology from The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary. I believe in a God who wants to be found; who leaves signs and suggestions, trademarks, signatures, and signposts scattered throughout every aspect of our existence. And if we are truly looking, He will find us. God is the great Story-teller, and the story he is telling is the great drama of Reality, unfolding before us and of which we are all inescapably a part. And so I am collecting fragments, in Philosophy, in Science, and in Art and holding these fragments up to the light and turning them this way and that, and trying to see and say how the Story—the metanarrative, the Christian Worldview—is involved in, and makes sense of, every aspect of our being-in-the-world (to borrow a term from Heidegger and take it where perhaps he did not intend for it to go). And by doing this I hope I am helping to light the way Home; back to the sea, the ocean, the Ocean of Infinite Love. My blog covers a wide range of topics around this central theme that the transcendent realm surrounds and permeates our existence. I put up new posts periodically. I hope you enjoy them. I hope they help.
This entry was posted in Philosophy, Popular Culture, Postmodernity and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Let me know what you think

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s